4D Silk Fiber Lash Mascara - Natural Waterproof, Smudge-proof, Thickening & Lengthening, No Clumping, Lasts All Day

Best mascara, beats the most expensive ones. It doesn’t end up looking like I have black eyes at days end. Washes off easy but doesn’t smudge. Will buy again

This is the best mascara that I've ever used. Great length!

I bought several "smudge proof" mascaras to find one that lives up to the hype. This one performed! I tested by applying to clean lashes before bed. It survived all night without smudging. I then showered and most came off. The small amount left came off with makeup remover. Bonus on cute container. The only thing that could improve is it didn't have the thick/lengthening of some other mascaras, but overall a nice look. Will buy again

Surprisingly good! Just make sure you take it off before bed it is harder than I thought to remove but a good micelar water should work.

Actually not sweat proof. So not waterproof. Had it coming off my lashes and onto my bottom lids. But it does look nice while on. So I’m mixed. It doesn’t run, just not completely waterproof.

My usual waterproof mascara was bleeding under my eyes, making me look like a skunk! Tried this one and no more black eyes…. And easy to remove!

I love this mascara! Gonna order more!

I love this mascara but I am sadly switching to a different brand because when washing this mascara off, black chunks get everywhere! When I shower and wash my face , its black specks all over the shower curtain and tub. When I wash my face at the sink, black specks get stuck the sink! I have never had a mascara do this before. And although I really like the product and it washes off my eyes easily, Im left with a mess to scrub clean when Im done.

This is a great product, at a fantastic price point. Its water and sweatproof but still easily cleans off your lashes at the end of the day. I love the look length on my lashes, with very little chunking! I'm also highly sensitive to most mascaras and find no allergies at all with this product.

I have very sensitive eyes and this mascara beats out all the drug store and expensive name brands my eyes love this mascara It's true to its claimed details no smudge and waterproof but not difficult to wash off. Have been using this for years!

In a former review I thought I was reviewing eyeliner. This is cruelty free which means a lot to me. I little flaky and extra time in removing but overall I am satisfied

I was convinced to buy this mascara due to all the super positive reviews. Reviewers, as you can see, rave about the lengthening and thickening properties of this mascara. There are even photos! Which makes me wonder if I received the same product as everyone else? **What I like about this mascara: It is a nice glossy black. It separates lashes REALLY well. It does not clump. It does not cause your lashes to stick together. It stays on nicely throughout the day. I even put this mascara on my bottom lashes, which typically causes me to get black raccoon eyes - but the mascara stays put on my bottom (and top) lashes. **What I don't like about this mascara: I could not discern much lengthening, and absolutely NO thickening, even after multiple coats. **BOTTOM-LINE: If you would like a natural looking mascara, that is glossy black, separates lashes well & does not melt or run, even on the bottom lashes, then this is the mascara for you. If you are expecting dramatic lengthening and ANY thickening, I would give this one a pass.

This mascara is awesome! It lengthens, separates lashes and thickens all in a stroke. It's a perfect wand, because it is slim enough so that you can get at your lower lashes, and outer corners to accentuate, with no blobs of any sort. I'm loving it!